Formulario para revisión
Is the summary adequate?
Are the keywords appropriate?
Is the method, strategy, intervention or experiment suitable, applicable and replicable?
Is the declared objective achieved?
Is adequate and updated bibliography cited for the development of the topic?
Do you consider that the conclusions are in accordance with the information presented?
Should the material be revised in terms of style, spelling and grammar?
How would you rate this manuscript?
Outstanding |
( ) |
Very good__ |
( ) |
Good |
( ) |
Regular |
( ) |
Deficient |
( ) |
Is the article acceptable for publication?
Yes, in its current form. |
( ) |
Yes, with some modifications |
( ) |
Yes, after an important revision |
( ) |
No, it must be rejected. |
( ) |
Comments:
-
-
-
-